Sunday, December 5, 2021

California Prop 47

"Property crime dropped significantly since then despite the recent high-profile cases, Newsom said. State crime statistics show property crimes dipped 7.7% last year, led by a nearly 15% drop in larceny thefts and 4% drop in burglaries."

Newsom was right to defend Prop 47. It's too easy but misguided to attribute the recent smash and grabs around the state to Prop 47.

Since 2014, there have been several studies, including this one by Charis Kubrin at the University of California Irvine, that could not detect any association between Prop 47 and any crime increases in California. 

A simple look at the trends in property crime rates before and after Prop 47's enactment don't support the idea that it's causing crime to increase. For one, despite some variation, crime has trended downward for all property crimes.  

Violent crime is a slightly different situation. Rates were increasing before Prop 47's passage and continued to trend upward in the several years after, but overall violent crimes leveled off, with some such as robbery decreasing for the last three years. 

Bottom line is that we should be skeptical of media claims and those working in the system who seek to attribute Prop 47 to negative changes in crime. It's almost certainly an attribution bias, one that doesn't take into account the longer crime trends and direction of trends since 2015.


1 comment:

California Prop 47

"Property crime dropped significantly since then despite the recent high-profile cases, Newsom said. State crime statistics show prope...